
HL Paper 2
The table gives data for Jupiter and three of its moons, including the radius r of each object.
A spacecraft is to be sent from to infinity.
Calculate, for the surface of , the gravitational field strength gIo due to the mass of . State an appropriate unit for your answer.
Show that the is about 80.
Outline, using (b)(i), why it is not correct to use the equation to calculate the speed required for the spacecraft to reach infinity from the surface of .
An engineer needs to move a space probe of mass 3600 kg from Ganymede to Callisto. Calculate the energy required to move the probe from the orbital radius of Ganymede to the orbital radius of Callisto. Ignore the mass of the moons in your calculation.
Markscheme
✓
N kg−1 OR m s−2 ✓
AND seen ✓
✓
For MP1, potentials can be seen individually or as a ratio.
«this is the escape speed for alone but» gravitational potential / field of Jupiter must be taken into account ✓
OWTTE
✓
« multiplies by 3600 kg to get » 1.9 × 1011 «J» ✓
Award [2] marks if factor of ½ used, taking into account orbital kinetic energies, leading to a final answer of 9.4 x 1010 «J».
Allow ECF from MP1
Award [2] marks for a bald correct answer.
Examiners report
Rhodium-106 () decays into palladium-106 () by beta minus (β–) decay. The diagram shows some of the nuclear energy levels of rhodium-106 and palladium-106. The arrow represents the β– decay.
Bohr modified the Rutherford model by introducing the condition mvr = n. Outline the reason for this modification.
Show that the speed v of an electron in the hydrogen atom is related to the radius r of the orbit by the expression
where k is the Coulomb constant.
Using the answer in (b) and (c)(i), deduce that the radius r of the electron’s orbit in the ground state of hydrogen is given by the following expression.
Calculate the electron’s orbital radius in (c)(ii).
Explain what may be deduced about the energy of the electron in the β– decay.
Suggest why the β– decay is followed by the emission of a gamma ray photon.
Calculate the wavelength of the gamma ray photon in (d)(ii).
Markscheme
the electrons accelerate and so radiate energy
they would therefore spiral into the nucleus/atoms would be unstable
electrons have discrete/only certain energy levels
the only orbits where electrons do not radiate are those that satisfy the Bohr condition «mvr = n»
[3 marks]
OR
KE = PE hence mev2 =
«solving for v to get answer»
Answer given – look for correct working
[1 mark]
combining v = with mevr = using correct substitution
«eg »
correct algebraic manipulation to gain the answer
Answer given – look for correct working
Do not allow a bald statement of the answer for MP2. Some further working eg cancellation of m or r must be shown
[2 marks]
« r = »
r = 5.3 × 10–11 «m»
[1 mark]
the energy released is 3.54 – 0.48 = 3.06 «MeV»
this is shared by the electron and the antineutrino
so the electron’s energy varies from 0 to 3.06 «MeV»
[3 marks]
the palladium nucleus emits the photon when it decays into the ground state «from the excited state»
[1 mark]
Photon energy
E = 0.48 × 106 × 1.6 × 10–19 = «7.68 × 10–14 J»
λ = « =» 2.6 × 10–12 «m»
Award [2] for a bald correct answer
Allow ECF from incorrect energy
[2 marks]
Examiners report
The moon Phobos moves around the planet Mars in a circular orbit.
Outline the origin of the force that acts on Phobos.
Outline why this force does no work on Phobos.
The orbital period T of a moon orbiting a planet of mass M is given by
where R is the average distance between the centre of the planet and the centre of the moon.
Show that
The following data for the Mars–Phobos system and the Earth–Moon system are available:
Mass of Earth = 5.97 × 1024 kg
The Earth–Moon distance is 41 times the Mars–Phobos distance.
The orbital period of the Moon is 86 times the orbital period of Phobos.
Calculate, in kg, the mass of Mars.
The graph shows the variation of the gravitational potential between the Earth and Moon with distance from the centre of the Earth. The distance from the Earth is expressed as a fraction of the total distance between the centre of the Earth and the centre of the Moon.
Determine, using the graph, the mass of the Moon.
Markscheme
gravitational attraction/force/field «of the planet/Mars» ✔
Do not accept “gravity”.
the force/field and the velocity/displacement are at 90° to each other OR
there is no change in GPE of the moon/Phobos ✔
ALTERNATE 1
«using fundamental equations»
use of Universal gravitational force/acceleration/orbital velocity equations ✔
equating to centripetal force or acceleration. ✔
rearranges to get ✔
ALTERNATE 2
«starting with »
substitution of proper equation for T from orbital motion equations ✔
substitution of proper equation for M OR R from orbital motion equations ✔
rearranges to get ✔
or other consistent re-arrangement ✔
6.4 × 1023 «kg» ✔
read off separation at maximum potential 0.9 ✔
equating of gravitational field strength of earth and moon at that location OR ✔
7.4 × 1022 «kg» ✔
Allow ECF from MP1
Examiners report
This was generally well answered, although some candidates simply used the vague term “gravity” rather than specifying that it is a gravitational force or a gravitational field. Candidates need to be reminded about using proper physics terms and not more general, “every day” terms on the exam.
Some candidates connected the idea that the gravitational force is perpendicular to the velocity (and hence the displacement) for the mark. It was also allowed to discuss that there is no change in gravitational potential energy, so therefore no work was being done. It was not acceptable to simply state that the net displacement over one full orbit is zero. Unfortunately, some candidates suggested that there is no net force on the moon so there is no work done, or that the moon is so much smaller so no work could be done on it.
This was another “show that” derivation. Many candidates attempted to work with universal gravitation equations, either from memory or the data booklet, to perform this derivation. The variety of correct solution paths was quite impressive, and many candidates who attempted this question were able to receive some marks. Candidates should be reminded on “show that” questions that it is never allowed to work backwards from the given answer. Some candidates also made up equations (such as T = 2𝝿r) to force the derivation to work out.
This question was challenging for candidates. The candidates who started down the correct path of using the given derived value from 5bi often simply forgot that the multiplication factors had to be squared and cubed as well as the variables.
This question was left blank by many candidates, and very few who attempted it were able to successfully recognize that the gravitational fields of the Earth and Moon balance at 0.9r and then use the proper equation to calculate the mass of the Moon.
A planet is in a circular orbit around a star. The speed of the planet is constant. The following data are given:
Mass of planet kg
Mass of star kg
Distance from the star to the planet R m.
A spacecraft is to be launched from the surface of the planet to escape from the star system. The radius of the planet is 9.1 × 103 km.
Explain why a centripetal force is needed for the planet to be in a circular orbit.
Calculate the value of the centripetal force.
Show that the gravitational potential due to the planet and the star at the surface of the planet is about −5 × 109 J kg−1.
Estimate the escape speed of the spacecraft from the planet–star system.
Markscheme
«circular motion» involves a changing velocity ✓
«Tangential velocity» is «always» perpendicular to centripetal force/acceleration ✓
there must be a force/acceleration towards centre/star ✓
without a centripetal force the planet will move in a straight line ✓
«N» ✓
Vplanet = «−»«−» 5.9 × 107 «J kg−1» ✓
Vstar = «−»«−» 4.9 × 109 «J kg−1» ✓
Vplanet + Vstar = «−» 4.9 «09» × 109 «J kg−1» ✓
Must see substitutions and not just equations.
use of vesc = ✓
v = 9.91 × 104 «m s−1» ✓
Examiners report
A planet has radius R. At a distance h above the surface of the planet the gravitational field strength is g and the gravitational potential is V.
State what is meant by gravitational field strength.
Show that V = –g(R + h).
Draw a graph, on the axes, to show the variation of the gravitational potential V of the planet with height h above the surface of the planet.
A planet has a radius of 3.1 × 106 m. At a point P a distance 2.4 × 107 m above the surface of the planet the gravitational field strength is 2.2 N kg–1. Calculate the gravitational potential at point P, include an appropriate unit for your answer.
The diagram shows the path of an asteroid as it moves past the planet.
When the asteroid was far away from the planet it had negligible speed. Estimate the speed of the asteroid at point P as defined in (b).
The mass of the asteroid is 6.2 × 1012 kg. Calculate the gravitational force experienced by the planet when the asteroid is at point P.
Markscheme
the «gravitational» force per unit mass exerted on a point/small/test mass
[1 mark]
at height h potential is V = –
field is g =
«dividing gives answer»
Do not allow an answer that starts with g = – and then cancels the deltas and substitutes R + h
[2 marks]
correct shape and sign
non-zero negative vertical intercept
[2 marks]
V = «–2.2 × (3.1 × 106 + 2.4 × 107) =» «–» 6.0 × 107 J kg–1
Unit is essential
Allow eg MJ kg–1 if power of 10 is correct
Allow other correct SI units eg m2s–2, N m kg–1
[1 mark]
total energy at P = 0 / KE gained = GPE lost
«mv2 + mV = 0 ⇒» v =
v = « =» 1.1 × 104 «ms–1»
Award [3] for a bald correct answer
Ignore negative sign errors in the workings
Allow ECF from 6(b)
[3 marks]
ALTERNATIVE 1
force on asteroid is «6.2 × 1012 × 2.2 =» 1.4 × 1013 «N»
«by Newton’s third law» this is also the force on the planet
ALTERNATIVE 2
mass of planet = 2.4 x 1025 «kg» «from V = –»
force on planet «» = 1.4 × 1013 «N»
MP2 must be explicit
[2 marks]
Examiners report
There is a proposal to place a satellite in orbit around planet Mars.
The satellite is to have an orbital time T equal to the length of a day on Mars. It can be shown that
T2 = kR3
where R is the orbital radius of the satellite and k is a constant.
The ratio = 1.5.
Outline what is meant by gravitational field strength at a point.
Newton’s law of gravitation applies to point masses. Suggest why the law can be applied to a satellite orbiting Mars.
Mars has a mass of 6.4 × 1023 kg. Show that, for Mars, k is about 9 × 10–13 s2 m–3.
The time taken for Mars to revolve on its axis is 8.9 × 104 s. Calculate, in m s–1, the orbital speed of the satellite.
Show that the intensity of solar radiation at the orbit of Mars is about 600 W m–2.
Determine, in K, the mean surface temperature of Mars. Assume that Mars acts as a black body.
The atmosphere of Mars is composed mainly of carbon dioxide and has a pressure less than 1 % of that on the Earth. Outline why the mean temperature of Earth is strongly affected by gases in its atmosphere but that of Mars is not.
Markscheme
force per unit mass ✔
acting on a small/test/point mass «placed at the point in the field» ✔
Mars is spherical/a sphere «and of uniform density so behaves as a point mass» ✔
satellite has a much smaller mass/diameter/size than Mars «so approximates to a point mass» ✔
« hence» . Also
OR
hence ✔
uses either of the above to get
OR
uses ✔
k = 9.2 × 10−13 / 9.3 × 10−13
Unit not required
R = 2.04 × 107 «m» ✔
v = «» 1.4 × 103 «m s–1»
OR
v = «» 1.4 × 103 «m s–1» ✔
use of «1.36 × 103 × » ✔
604 «W m–2» ✔
use of for mean intensity ✔
temperature/K = «» 230 ✔
reference to greenhouse gas/effect ✔
recognize the link between molecular density/concentration and pressure ✔
low pressure means too few molecules to produce a significant heating effect
OR
low pressure means too little radiation re-radiated back to Mars ✔
The greenhouse effect can be described, it doesn’t have to be named
Examiners report
Titan is a moon of Saturn. The Titan-Sun distance is 9.3 times greater than the Earth-Sun distance.
The molar mass of nitrogen is 28 g mol−1.
Show that the intensity of the solar radiation at the location of Titan is 16 W m−2.
Titan has an atmosphere of nitrogen. The albedo of the atmosphere is 0.22. The surface of Titan may be assumed to be a black body. Explain why the average intensity of solar radiation absorbed by the whole surface of Titan is 3.1 W m−2.
Show that the equilibrium surface temperature of Titan is about 90 K.
The mass of Titan is 0.025 times the mass of the Earth and its radius is 0.404 times the radius of the Earth. The escape speed from Earth is 11.2 km s−1. Show that the escape speed from Titan is 2.8 km s−1.
The orbital radius of Titan around Saturn is and the period of revolution is .
Show that where is the mass of Saturn.
The orbital radius of Titan around Saturn is 1.2 × 109 m and the orbital period is 15.9 days. Estimate the mass of Saturn.
Show that the mass of a nitrogen molecule is 4.7 × 10−26 kg.
Estimate the root mean square speed of nitrogen molecules in the Titan atmosphere. Assume an atmosphere temperature of 90 K.
Discuss, by reference to the answer in (b), whether it is likely that Titan will lose its atmosphere of nitrogen.
Markscheme
incident intensity OR «W m−2» ✓
Allow the use of 1400 for the solar constant.
exposed surface is ¼ of the total surface ✓
absorbed intensity = (1−0.22) × incident intensity ✓
0.78 × 0.25 × 15.7 OR 3.07 «W m−2» ✓
Allow 3.06 from rounding and 3.12 if they use 16 W m−2.
σT 4 = 3.07
OR
T = 86 «K» ✓
OR
«km s−1» ✓
correct equating of gravitational force / acceleration to centripetal force / acceleration ✓
correct rearrangement to reach the expression given ✓
Allow use of for MP1.
«s» ✓
«kg» ✓
Award [2] marks for a bald correct answer.
Allow ECF from MP1.
OR
«kg» ✓
✓
«ms−1» ✓
Award [2] marks for a bald correct answer.
Allow 282 from a rounded mass.
no, molecular speeds much less than escape speed ✓
Allow ECF from incorrect (d)(ii).
Examiners report
A proton moves along a circular path in a region of a uniform magnetic field. The magnetic field is directed into the plane of the page.
The speed of the proton is 2.16 × 106 m s-1 and the magnetic field strength is 0.042 T.
Label with arrows on the diagram the magnetic force F on the proton.
Label with arrows on the diagram the velocity vector v of the proton.
For this proton, determine, in m, the radius of the circular path. Give your answer to an appropriate number of significant figures.
For this proton, calculate, in s, the time for one full revolution.
Markscheme
F towards centre ✔
v tangent to circle and in the direction shown in the diagram ✔
« ✔
R = 0.538«m» ✔
R = 0.54«m» ✔
✔
«s» ✔
Examiners report
Examiners were requested to be lenient here and as a result most candidates scored both marks. Had we insisted on e.g. straight lines drawn with a ruler or a force arrow passing exactly through the centre of the circle very few marks would have been scored. For those who didn’t know which way the arrows were supposed to be the common guesses were to the left and up the page. Some candidates neglected to label the arrows.
Examiners were requested to be lenient here and as a result most candidates scored both marks. Had we insisted on e.g. straight lines drawn with a ruler or a force arrow passing exactly through the centre of the circle very few marks would have been scored. For those who didn’t know which way the arrows were supposed to be the common guesses were to the left and up the page. Some candidates neglected to label the arrows.
This was generally well answered although usually to 3 sf. Common mistakes were to substitute 0.042 for F and 1 for q. Also some candidates tried to answer in terms of electric fields.
This was well answered with many candidates scoring ECF from the previous part.
The ball is now displaced through a small distance x from the bottom of the bowl and is then released from rest.
The magnitude of the force on the ball towards the equilibrium position is given by
where R is the radius of the bowl.
A small ball of mass m is moving in a horizontal circle on the inside surface of a frictionless hemispherical bowl.
The normal reaction force N makes an angle θ to the horizontal.
State the direction of the resultant force on the ball.
On the diagram, construct an arrow of the correct length to represent the weight of the ball.
Show that the magnitude of the net force F on the ball is given by the following equation.
The radius of the bowl is 8.0 m and θ = 22°. Determine the speed of the ball.
Outline whether this ball can move on a horizontal circular path of radius equal to the radius of the bowl.
Outline why the ball will perform simple harmonic oscillations about the equilibrium position.
Show that the period of oscillation of the ball is about 6 s.
The amplitude of oscillation is 0.12 m. On the axes, draw a graph to show the variation with time t of the velocity v of the ball during one period.
A second identical ball is placed at the bottom of the bowl and the first ball is displaced so that its height from the horizontal is equal to 8.0 m.
The first ball is released and eventually strikes the second ball. The two balls remain in contact. Determine, in m, the maximum height reached by the two balls.
Markscheme
towards the centre «of the circle» / horizontally to the right
Do not accept towards the centre of the bowl
[1 mark]
downward vertical arrow of any length
arrow of correct length
Judge the length of the vertical arrow by eye. The construction lines are not required. A label is not required
eg:
[2 marks]
ALTERNATIVE 1
F = N cos θ
mg = N sin θ
dividing/substituting to get result
ALTERNATIVE 2
right angle triangle drawn with F, N and W/mg labelled
angle correctly labelled and arrows on forces in correct directions
correct use of trigonometry leading to the required relationship
tan θ =
[3 marks]
= m
r = R cos θ
v =
v = 13.4/13 «ms –1»
Award [4] for a bald correct answer
Award [3] for an answer of 13.9/14 «ms –1». MP2 omitted
[4 marks]
there is no force to balance the weight/N is horizontal
so no / it is not possible
Must see correct justification to award MP2
[2 marks]
the «restoring» force/acceleration is proportional to displacement
Direction is not required
[1 mark]
ω = «» = «= 1.107 s–1»
T = « = =» 5.7 «s»
Allow use of or g = 9.8 or 10
Award [0] for a substitution into T = 2π
[2 marks]
sine graph
correct amplitude «0.13 m s–1»
correct period and only 1 period shown
Accept ± sine for shape of the graph. Accept 5.7 s or 6.0 s for the correct period.
Amplitude should be correct to ± square for MP2
eg: v /m s–1
[3 marks]
speed before collision v = « =» 12.5 «ms–1»
«from conservation of momentum» common speed after collision is initial speed «vc = = 6.25 ms–1»
h = «» 2.0 «m»
Allow 12.5 from incorrect use of kinematics equations
Award [3] for a bald correct answer
Award [0] for mg(8) = 2mgh leading to h = 4 m if done in one step.
Allow ECF from MP1
Allow ECF from MP2
[3 marks]
Examiners report
The gravitational potential due to the Sun at its surface is –1.9 x 1011 J kg–1. The following data are available.
Mass of Earth | = 6.0 x 1024 kg |
Distance from Earth to Sun | = 1.5 x 1011 m |
Radius of Sun | = 7.0 x 108 m |
Outline why the gravitational potential is negative.
The gravitational potential due to the Sun at a distance r from its centre is VS. Show that
rVS = constant.
Calculate the gravitational potential energy of the Earth in its orbit around the Sun. Give your answer to an appropriate number of significant figures.
Calculate the total energy of the Earth in its orbit.
An asteroid strikes the Earth and causes the orbital speed of the Earth to suddenly decrease. Suggest the ways in which the orbit of the Earth will change.
Outline, in terms of the force acting on it, why the Earth remains in a circular orbit around the Sun.
Markscheme
potential is defined to be zero at infinity
so a positive amount of work needs to be supplied for a mass to reach infinity
VS = so r x VS «= –GM» = constant because G and M are constants
GM = 1.33 x 1020 «J m kg–1»
GPE at Earth orbit «= –» = «–» 5.3 x 1033 «J»
Award [1 max] unless answer is to 2 sf.
Ignore addition of Sun radius to radius of Earth orbit.
ALTERNATIVE 1
work leading to statement that kinetic energy , AND kinetic energy evaluated to be «+» 2.7 x 1033 «J»
energy «= PE + KE = answer to (b)(ii) + 2.7 x 1033» = «–» 2.7 x 1033 «J»
ALTERNATIVE 2
statement that kinetic energy is gravitational potential energy in orbit
so energy «» = «–» 2.7 x 1033 «J»
Various approaches possible.
«KE will initially decrease so» total energy decreases
OR
«KE will initially decrease so» total energy becomes more negative
Earth moves closer to Sun
new orbit with greater speed «but lower total energy»
changes ellipticity of orbit
centripetal force is required
and is provided by gravitational force between Earth and Sun
Award [1 max] for statement that there is a “centripetal force of gravity” without further qualification.